IFR Alternates: When You Need One and Which Airport Qualifies

IFR Alternates: When You Need One and Which Airport Qualifies

by

17 min read


An alternate airport is an airport where you can land if landing at your intended airport becomes inadvisable (Pilot/Controller Glossary). An instrument flight rules (IFR) flight plan must name one unless the flight meets the exception in 14 CFR 91.169.

Planning one takes two decisions: whether your flight plan needs an alternate at all, and whether the airport you choose qualifies as one.

Alternates at a glance (14 CFR 91.169, for airplanes; AIM for GPS)

  • When you need one: always, unless ATC (air traffic control) authorizes otherwise, or the destination has an instrument approach and the forecast from 1 hour before to 1 hour after your ETA (estimated time of arrival) shows a ceiling of at least 2,000 feet above the airport and visibility of at least 3 statute miles (the 1-2-3 rule).
  • What weather the alternate needs, at your ETA there:
    • the alternate minimums published for the approach you plan to fly, or
    • if none are published, 600-2 for a precision approach such as an ILS (instrument landing system), or 800-2 for a nonprecision approach, including RNAV (area navigation) approaches based on GPS (Global Positioning System), or
    • if it has no instrument approach, weather that allows a descent from the MEA (minimum en route altitude), approach and landing under basic VFR (visual flight rules).
  • On the chart: a triangle A means the approach has nonstandard alternate minimums or restrictions, listed at the front of the TPP (Terminal Procedures Publication). "A NA" (not authorized) means you can't use that approach for an alternate.
  • GPS: without WAAS (Wide Area Augmentation System), and with FDE (fault detection and exclusion) and a RAIM (receiver autonomous integrity monitoring) prediction, plan a GPS approach at the destination or the alternate, not both. With WAAS, plan a GPS approach at the alternate on the LNAV (lateral navigation) or circling line (AIM, Aeronautical Information Manual, 1-1-17 and 1-1-18).
  • Forecast groups: TEMPO (temporary) and PROB30 (30% probability) groups in a TAF (terminal aerodrome forecast) are part of the forecast. Check them against both tests.

Do you need an alternate? The 1-2-3 rule

Every IFR flight plan must list an alternate airport, unless ATC authorizes otherwise or the flight meets one exception (14 CFR 91.169(a)). Both of its conditions must hold (91.169(b)):

  1. The first airport of intended landing has a published instrument approach (a standard procedure in 14 CFR Part 97, or a special procedure issued to the operator).
  2. Weather reports, forecasts or a combination of them show that, for at least 1 hour before and for 1 hour after your ETA, the ceiling will be at least 2,000 feet above the airport elevation and the visibility at least 3 statute miles.

The Instrument Procedures Handbook (IPH) calls this the "1, 2, 3 Rule": 1 hour either side of the ETA, a 2,000-foot ceiling, 3 miles (IPH, chapter 1).

If either condition fails, you need an alternate. A destination with no instrument approach always needs one. These figures are for airplanes. Helicopters have their own in 91.169(b)(2)(ii) and (c)(1)(ii).

A timeline from 1600Z to 2100Z with the ETA at 1800Z and the two-hour window from 1700Z to 1900Z shaded. Under it, the forecast groups from example 1: the prevailing group from 1600Z with a broken ceiling at 3,000 feet and 6 miles, and a TEMPO group from 1700Z to 2000Z with a broken ceiling at 1,500 feet and 2 miles. The TEMPO group overlaps the window, so the forecast fails the 1-2-3 test.
The window is two hours wide, centered on your ETA. Any forecast group that overlaps it counts. The TAF is the one from example 1.

What counts as a ceiling

A ceiling is the lowest layer of clouds or obscuring phenomena reported as broken, overcast or obscuration, and not as thin or partial (14 CFR 1.1). In a TAF that means:

  • BKN (broken) and OVC (overcast) are ceilings.
  • VV, the vertical visibility into a surface-based obscuration, is an indefinite ceiling. VV008, BKN008 and OVC008 all indicate an 800-foot ceiling (National Weather Service, NWS, Instruction 10-813, B2.7.1 and B2.7.2).
  • FEW (few) and SCT (scattered) aren't ceilings. A forecast of SCT008 OVC025 has a ceiling of 2,500 feet.

TAF cloud heights are forecast above ground level (NWS Instruction 10-813, B2.7.1), so you can compare them directly with the 2,000 feet above the airport elevation.

The fuel follows the same rule

When you need an alternate, you also need the fuel to fly to the destination, then to the alternate, then 45 minutes at normal cruising speed. If you meet the 1-2-3 exception, you still need fuel to the destination and then the 45 minutes (14 CFR 91.167).

Reading the TAF against the window

A TAF divides its valid period into groups. Read every group whose time overlaps your window, not only the one in effect at your ETA (NWS Instruction 10-813):

  • FM (from): a rapid change, in under an hour, to a new set of prevailing conditions. Each FM group replaces the conditions before it.
  • TEMPO (temporarily): fluctuations expected to last an hour or less each time and, in total, less than half of the period the group covers, which is at most 4 hours.
  • PROB30: a 30% chance of a thunderstorm or precipitation event, with the visibility and clouds that come with it. A PROB30 group covers at most 6 hours. Since October 2024 it may also appear in the first 9 hours of a TAF.

TEMPO and PROB30 count

Apply the conditions in a TEMPO or PROB30 group as you would the prevailing ones, both for the 1-2-3 test at the destination and for the alternate minimums at the alternate.

Part 121 airlines covered by a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) exemption, No. 3585, may dispatch domestic flights when conditional language in one time increment of a forecast is below their minimums and the other increments are at or above them (FAA Chief Counsel, letter to Frisch, 2011). No such exemption exists for Part 91.

If the destination has no TAF, the 1-2-3 test still needs weather reports or forecasts that show the conditions (91.169(b)(2)).

High-altitude destinations: when 1-2-3 isn't enough

The 1-2-3 rule doesn't check the destination's own approach minimums. At a few mountain airports every approach has an MDA (minimum descent altitude) more than 2,000 feet above the airport, or a visibility minimum above 3 miles. The AIM names three: Bishop and South Lake Tahoe in California, and Aspen in Colorado (AIM 5-1-10).

At those airports a forecast can relieve you of an alternate while the weather is below what any approach allows. Some other mountain airports have MDAs 1,700 to 1,900 feet above the airport. A small change from the forecast can put the weather below their minimums. The AIM cautions pilots flying to these airports to consider an alternate even when the forecast doesn't require one (AIM 5-1-10). Example 5 works through Aspen.

Does the airport qualify? Alternate minimums

To list an airport as your alternate, reports or forecasts must show that at your ETA at that airport, the ceiling and visibility will be at or above its alternate minimums (91.169(c)). The time is your arrival at the alternate, not at the destination.

The alternate has (91.169(c))Weather it needs at your ETA there
An approach with published alternate minimumsThose minimums
A precision approach with no published alternate minimums600-foot ceiling, 2 miles (600-2)
A nonprecision approach with no published alternate minimums800-foot ceiling, 2 miles (800-2)
No instrument approachEnough for a descent from the MEA, approach and landing under basic VFR (the weather minimums of 14 CFR 91.155)

Precision and nonprecision for alternate planning

For alternate planning, precision approaches are the ILS, PAR (precision approach radar) and GLS (ground-based augmentation system landing system). Nonprecision approaches include NDB (nondirectional beacon), VOR (very high frequency omnidirectional range), LOC (localizer), TACAN (tactical air navigation), LDA (localizer-type directional aid), ASR (airport surveillance radar), RNAV (GPS) and RNAV (RNP), where RNP is required navigation performance (TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums).

An RNAV (GPS) approach with an LPV (localizer performance with vertical guidance) line therefore counts as nonprecision. Plan it on 800-2 unless it has its own alternate minimums.

Category, equipment and the approach you plan

The approach you plan to fly sets the minimums, so the same airport can qualify on one approach and not on another. Whether it qualifies also depends on your category and equipment (IPH, chapter 1).

Your approach category comes from the airplane's reference landing speed (VREF), or 1.3 times its stalling speed in the landing configuration (VSO) if no VREF is specified, at maximum certificated landing weight. Category A is under 91 knots and Category B is 91 knots to less than 121 (14 CFR 97.3). Nonstandard alternate minimums are listed by category, so check yours.

Reading the chart: the triangle A and NA

Standard alternate minimums aren't printed on the approach charts. Nonstandard ones are listed in the IFR Alternate Airport Minimums section at the front of each TPP volume, and the approach chart marks them with a symbol (IPH, chapter 1):

  • Triangle A: the approach has nonstandard alternate minimums, restrictions, or both. Look up the airport in the alternate minimums section.
  • Triangle A with NA: you may not use that approach for an alternate, because of an unmonitored facility, no weather reporting service or a lack of navigation coverage. These approaches aren't listed in the section (TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums).
  • No symbol: standard minimums.

A procedure is also not authorized for alternate planning when local weather isn't available (TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums). An approach marked NA can't be used for alternate planning, even if the forecast would allow a VFR descent from the MEA (FAA Chief Counsel, letter to Lloyd, 2006). If it's the airport's only approach, the airport can't be your required alternate.

Colorado Springs: one airport, several minimums

The notes box of the ILS or LOC RWY 35R chart at Colorado Springs: a triangle T and a triangle A beside the note RADAR required when R-2601 in use
The notes box of ILS or LOC RWY 35R, Colorado Springs (COS), Amdt 2A, chart cycle of 29 October to 26 November 2026. The triangle A points to the alternate minimums section. Not for navigation.

The ILS or LOC RWY 35R chart at Colorado Springs carries the triangle A in its notes box. The airport's entry in the TPP's southwest volume lists eleven of its approaches, each with a footnote. Approaches not in the entry and without an NA, such as the RNAV (RNP) Z 35R, use the standard minimums.

The Colorado Springs entry in the IFR Alternate Airport Minimums: eleven approaches with footnotes. Note 2, ILS Cat B 700-2, Cat C 900-2½, Cat D 1100-3, LOC Cat C 900-2½, Cat D 1100-3. Note 4, LOC Cat A, B 1400-2, Cat C, D 1400-3. Note 5, Cat A, B 900-2, Cat C 900-2½, Cat D 1100-3. Note 3, Cat A, B, C, D 800-2½. Note 6, NA when local weather not available. Note 9, Cat A, B 1300-2, Cat C, D 1300-3.
Colorado Springs (COS) in the IFR Alternate Airport Minimums, SW-1, chart cycle of 29 October to 26 November 2026. Not for navigation.
COS approachCategory ACategory B
ILS or LOC 17LILS 600-2, LOC 1400-2; NA without local weatherSame
ILS or LOC 35LILS 600-2, LOC 800-2Same
ILS or LOC 35RILS 600-2, LOC 800-2ILS 700-2, LOC 800-2
NDB 35L; RNAV (GPS) 31, Y 17R, Y 35L, Y 35R800-2800-2
RNAV (GPS) Y 17L900-2900-2
RNAV (RNP) Z 17R800-2½800-2½
VOR 17L1300-21300-2

A footnote that doesn't name your category leaves you on the standard minimums. A triangle A doesn't always mean higher minimums for your airplane. At Centennial (APA), every footnote covers only Categories C and D, so a piston single uses 600-2 and 800-2 there.

GPS and WAAS at the alternate

The limits depend on whether your GPS has WAAS. Basic GPS means a receiver approved under TSO-C129 or TSO-C196 (Technical Standard Order). WAAS means TSO-C145 or TSO-C146.

Basic GPSWAAS
GPS approaches you may planAt the destination or the alternate, not bothAt both
ConditionsFDE, a RAIM prediction at the airport of the GPS approach, and the training to fly itApproach-approved WAAS avionics
Plan the alternate onLNAV or circling MDA; LNAV with vertical navigation (LNAV/VNAV) decision altitude (DA) only with approved barometric VNAV (baro-VNAV)The LNAV or circling line, with nonprecision weather; LNAV/VNAV DA only with approved baro-VNAV
If the GPS approach is at the destinationThe alternate needs an approach that doesn't use GPS, expected to be available at your ETA, that your airplane can flyGPS approaches may be planned at both airports

Sources: AIM 1-1-17, 1-1-18 and 1-2-3.

Without WAAS, when the GPS approach is at the destination, the approach you plan at the alternate can't use GPS even in place of a ground navaid (AIM 1-2-3). If that approach requires DME (distance measuring equipment) or an ADF (automatic direction finder), the airplane needs that equipment installed (IPH, chapter 1), and the same goes for a VOR used in an ILS missed approach. With WAAS, this substitution restriction doesn't apply (AIM 1-2-3).

Some RNAV (GPS) charts carry a W symbol, which means WAAS vertical guidance may fail there without a notice to air missions (NOTAM). Plan the LNAV or circling line at such an airport, as a destination or as an alternate (AIM 1-1-18).

The FAA is removing the NA from some RNAV (GPS) approaches so that WAAS users can plan them as alternates. Some keep it for other reasons, such as no weather reporting (AIM 1-1-18). The RNAV approach lesson covers the equipment and the RAIM check.

Alternate minimums are for planning

Alternate minimums decide whether you may list the airport on your flight plan. If you divert there, the approach's published landing minimums apply (IPH, chapter 4). With WAAS, if the receiver indicates LPV or LNAV/VNAV service when you arrive, you may use that vertical guidance (AIM 1-1-18).

Worked examples

The TAFs below are invented for this lesson. The charts and alternate minimums are real, from the cycle of 29 October to 26 November 2026.

Example 1: a TEMPO group in the window

Situation: you're flying to Centennial (APA), which has several instrument approaches. Your ETA is 1800Z. The forecast:

TAF KAPA 171130Z 1712/1812 34008KT P6SM SCT050
  FM171600 20010KT 6SM -SHRA BKN030
  TEMPO 1717/1720 2SM SHRA BKN015
  FM180000 30012KT P6SM SCT060
  1. Your window runs from 1700Z to 1900Z.
  2. The FM171600 group covers the whole window: ceiling 3,000 feet, 6 miles. On its own it meets 2,000 and 3.
  3. The TEMPO group runs from 1700Z to 2000Z and overlaps the window. It forecasts a 1,500-foot ceiling and 2 miles, below both.
  4. You need an alternate. If your ETA were 2130Z, the window would start at 2030Z, after the TEMPO group ends, and the forecast in it (BKN030 6SM) would meet the rule.

Example 2: the category decides the approach

Situation: for the flight in example 1, you consider Colorado Springs (COS) as the alternate. Your ETA there would be 1900Z, and its forecast covering that time is:

FM171700 33006KT 3SM BR OVC006
  1. The ceiling is 600 feet and the visibility 3 miles. Assume local weather is available, so note 6 doesn't apply.
  2. Category A: the ILS 35R needs 600-2 (the standard minimums, because note 2 doesn't cover Category A). The forecast 600-foot ceiling meets the 600 feet, and 3 miles exceeds the 2. COS qualifies.
  3. Category B: the ILS 35R needs 700-2 (note 2), and 600 is below 700. The ILS 17L needs 600-2, because note 4 covers only its LOC line. COS qualifies on the ILS 17L.

Example 3: basic GPS, GPS approach at the destination

Situation: your destination is Meadow Lake (FLY), near Colorado Springs, whose only approaches are RNAV (GPS). The forecast requires an alternate. Your GPS is TSO-C129 with FDE, the RAIM prediction for FLY is good, and the airplane also has ILS and VOR receivers and DME. You plan COS as the alternate.

  1. You're planning a GPS approach at FLY, so the alternate needs an approach that doesn't use GPS (AIM 1-1-17).
  2. At COS that excludes the RNAV (GPS) approaches. The ILS, LOC, VOR and NDB approaches remain, if the airplane can fly them. Without an ADF, the NDB 35L is also excluded.
  3. Plan COS on an ILS approach, which has the lowest alternate minimums in the table for your category. A LOC approach, or the VOR 17L at 1300-2, also qualifies if the forecast meets its minimums.

Example 4: WAAS, an RNAV (GPS) approach at the alternate

Situation: the same flight to FLY in a Category A airplane with an approach-approved WAAS receiver. You'd like to plan the RNAV (GPS) Y RWY 17L at COS, which has an LPV line. The forecast for your ETA there is BKN009 4SM.

  1. The destination-or-alternate limit doesn't apply to WAAS, so you may plan GPS approaches at both airports (AIM 1-2-3).
  2. Plan the alternate on the LNAV line with nonprecision weather, not on the LPV line.
  3. The RNAV (GPS) Y 17L has nonstandard alternate minimums of 900-2 for Categories A and B (note 5). The forecast 900-foot ceiling meets the 900 feet, and 4 miles exceeds the 2. COS qualifies on this approach.
  4. If you divert to COS and the receiver indicates LPV service, you may fly the LPV line to its DA.

Example 5: Aspen, where 1-2-3 is met

Situation: a daytime flight to Aspen (ASE), elevation 7,838 feet, in a Category B airplane. From 1 hour before to 1 hour after your ETA, the forecast is BKN022 5SM.

  1. Aspen has an instrument approach, and 2,200 feet and 5 miles meet 2,000 and 3. 91.169 doesn't require an alternate.
  2. Aspen's two instrument approaches, the LOC/DME-E and the RNAV (GPS)-F, have only circling minimums. For Category B both MDAs are 10,220 feet, 2,382 feet above the airport, with 3 miles on the LOC/DME-E and 1¾ on the RNAV. Both procedures are NA at night.
  3. A 2,200-foot ceiling is below 2,382 feet above the airport on either approach, so you shouldn't count on completing either approach (AIM 5-1-10). Consider an alternate, and the fuel to reach it, even though the rule doesn't require one.

On the checkride

Alternates are tested in Area of Operation I of the Instrument Rating Airman Certification Standards (ACS, FAA-S-ACS-8C). In Task B you determine whether an alternate is required, and whether the one you selected meets the regulations (IR.I.B.S4). Task C lists primary and alternate airports in route planning (IR.I.C.K1d).

Try it: IFR alternates

All questions are for an airplane under Part 91. The TAF lines are invented for practice; the Colorado Springs minimums are from the chart cycle of 29 October 2026.

10 questions, one at a time
  1. Your destination has an instrument approach. ETA 1500Z. Its TAF: FM141200 18010KT P6SM BKN040, then TEMPO 1415/1418 3SM -RA BKN018. Do you need an alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: B, Yes. The TEMPO group puts the ceiling below 2,000 feet inside the window. The window runs from 1400Z to 1600Z. The TEMPO group starts at 1500Z, inside it, and forecasts a 1,800-foot ceiling. Treat TEMPO and PROB30 groups like the prevailing forecast: the forecast no longer shows 2,000 feet for the whole window, so you need an alternate. The 3 miles alone would have met the rule.

    Reference: 14 CFR 91.169(b)(2)(i)

  2. Your destination has no instrument approach procedure. The forecast for 1 hour either side of your ETA is SKC, visibility 10 miles. Do you need to file an alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: C, Yes. The exception needs an instrument approach at the destination. The exception in 91.169(b) needs two conditions: a published instrument approach at the first airport of intended landing, and the 1-2-3 forecast. With no approach, the first condition fails, so an alternate is required whatever the weather.

    Reference: 14 CFR 91.169(b)(1)

  3. Your destination has an RNAV (GPS) approach. From 1 hour before to 1 hour after your ETA, the forecast is 5SM BR SCT008 BKN025. Does 91.169 require an alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: A, No. The ceiling is 2,500 feet and the visibility 5 miles. A ceiling is the lowest layer reported as broken, overcast or obscuration. A scattered layer isn't one, so the ceiling is the broken layer at 2,500 feet. With 5 miles, the forecast meets 2,000 and 3, and no alternate is required.

    Reference: 14 CFR 1.1, Ceiling; 14 CFR 91.169(b)

  4. You need an alternate. At what time must the forecast at the alternate meet its alternate minimums?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: C, At your ETA at the alternate. 91.169(c) applies the alternate minimums at the estimated time of arrival at the alternate airport. The two-hour window belongs to the 1-2-3 test at the destination.

    Reference: 14 CFR 91.169(c)

  5. Your alternate's only approach is an RNAV (GPS) with LPV, LNAV/VNAV and LNAV lines. The chart has no triangle A. Your airplane has WAAS and no baro-VNAV. What weather must the forecast show at your ETA there?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: B, 800-2, the nonprecision standard, planning on the LNAV line. For alternate planning, RNAV (GPS) approaches are nonprecision, and with WAAS you plan the LNAV or circling line with the Part 91 nonprecision weather: 800-2 when the chart lists nothing else. If LPV is available when you arrive, you may use it.

    Reference: AIM 1-1-18; TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums; IPH, chapter 4

  6. Colorado Springs (COS) lists the ILS or LOC RWY 35R with note 2: "ILS Cat B 700-2, Cat C 900-2½, Cat D 1100-3; LOC Cat C 900-2½, Cat D 1100-3." What are the alternate minimums on the ILS for a Category A airplane?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: A, 600-2, the standard precision minimums. The note sets nonstandard minimums only for the categories it names. Category A isn't named, so the standard precision minimums of 600-2 apply. A Category B airplane would need 700-2 on the same approach.

    Reference: TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums (SW-1, cycle 2611); 14 CFR 91.169(c)(1)(i)

  7. Your GPS is TSO-C129 with FDE, not WAAS. Your destination's only approaches are RNAV (GPS), and you plan to fly one. Which airport can you plan as the alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: B, One with an ILS your airplane can fly. Without WAAS you may plan a GPS-based approach at the destination or the alternate, not both. Since you plan one at the destination, the alternate needs an approach that doesn't use GPS, expected to be available at your ETA, that the airplane is equipped to fly. Using GPS in place of the ground navaid there isn't allowed either.

    Reference: AIM 1-1-17 and 1-2-3

  8. You need an alternate. A nearby airport has no instrument approach. When can you list it as your alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: A, When the forecast for your ETA there allows a descent from the MEA, approach and landing under basic VFR. For an alternate with no instrument approach, 91.169(c)(2) requires weather that allows a descent from the MEA, approach and landing under basic VFR (the weather minimums of 91.155). It's a different case from a destination with no approach, which always needs an alternate, and from an approach marked NA, which can't be used whatever the forecast.

    Reference: 14 CFR 91.169(c)(2)

  9. The only approach at a nearby airport carries a triangle A with NA. Its forecast for your ETA is clear with 10 miles, good enough for a VFR descent from the MEA. Can you list it as your required alternate?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: C, No. An approach marked NA can't be used for an alternate. NA means alternate minimums are not authorized for that approach, because of an unmonitored facility, no weather reporting or a lack of navigation coverage. The FAA's Chief Counsel has said such an airport can't be listed as a required alternate even when the forecast would allow a VFR descent from the MEA.

    Reference: TPP, IFR Alternate Airport Minimums; FAA Chief Counsel, letter to Lloyd (2006)

  10. You're flying to a mountain airport in daylight. Its forecast meets 2,000 and 3 for 1 hour either side of your ETA, but its only approaches are circling, with an MDA 2,382 feet above the airport. What applies?

    Choose one answer
    Show the answer

    Answer: A, 91.169 doesn't require an alternate, but the AIM cautions you to consider one. The 1-2-3 rule checks the forecast, not the destination's minimums, so no alternate is required. AIM 5-1-10 names airports like this (Aspen among them) where the forecast can relieve you of an alternate while the weather is below every approach, and cautions you to consider one anyway.

    Reference: 14 CFR 91.169(b); AIM 5-1-10

Source: 14 CFR 91.169 and 1.1 (eCFR); AIM 1-1-17, 1-1-18, 1-2-3 and 5-1-10 (Change 3, July 2026); IPH (FAA-H-8083-16B), chapters 1 and 4; FAA TPP, cycle of 29 October 2026.

Next step

Sources and review

Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.



Last Updated:

This post may contain affiliate links or advertisements. This means I earn a small commission if you decide to make a purchase through the links at no extra cost to you.